The Eagles Nest Player of the Year 2010

5 - Cicolella
4 - Polec
3 - Grieger
2 - Parry
1 - McKenzie

5 Cicca
4 Grieger
3 Parry
2 Macca
1 Polec

5 - McKenzie
4 - Rowntree
3 - Cicca
2 - Polac
1 - Parry

Was very difficult to pick 5 players this week... in the end I went for guys who showed commitment & effort for the ENTIRE game

5 - Polec
4 - Rowntree
3- Cicca
2 - McKenzie
1 - Jarrad

5 Cicca
4 Polec
3 Grieger
2 Macca
1 Parry

God help the Eagles when Cicca decides to call it a day.
Yes, he makes an odd mistake. Yes, at times, he carries an injury.
BUT! He always gives 100%

5) Polec
4) Cicolella
3) McKenzie
2) Allmond
1) Parry

Thought it was Jarrad Allmond's best game for a long time. Twenty three tackles will not win games for the Eagles.

Flash wrote:5 Cicca
4 Polec
3 Grieger
2 Macca
1 Parry

God help the Eagles when Cicca decides to call it a day.
Yes, he makes an odd mistake. Yes, at times, he carries an injury.
BUT! He always gives 100%

Couldn't agree more Flash. Hopefully, because he has been managed very well this year by Gods his old body may be able to go on for another year, we can only hope.
5 - Cicolella
4 - Polec
3 - Rowntree
2 - Allmond
1 - McKenzie

Eagle014 wrote:

Flash wrote:5 Cicca
4 Polec
3 Grieger
2 Macca
1 Parry

God help the Eagles when Cicca decides to call it a day.
Yes, he makes an odd mistake. Yes, at times, he carries an injury.
BUT! He always gives 100%

Couldn't agree more Flash. Hopefully, because he has been managed very well this year by Gods his old body may be able to go on for another year, we can only hope.
5 - Cicolella
4 - Polec
3 - Rowntree
2 - Allmond
1 - McKenzie

When Cica retires im going to be so sad he has been my favourite player since i started following the Eagles when i was 4. It was also his first year at the Eagles so i have had his number on my gurnsey since he joined the Eags

Kaitlyn51 wrote:

Eagle014 wrote:

Flash wrote:5 Cicca
4 Polec
3 Grieger
2 Macca
1 Parry

God help the Eagles when Cicca decides to call it a day.
Yes, he makes an odd mistake. Yes, at times, he carries an injury.
BUT! He always gives 100%

Couldn't agree more Flash. Hopefully, because he has been managed very well this year by Gods his old body may be able to go on for another year, we can only hope.
5 - Cicolella
4 - Polec
3 - Rowntree
2 - Allmond
1 - McKenzie

When Cica retires im going to be so sad he has been my favourite player since i started following the Eagles when i was 4. It was also his first year at the Eagles so i have had his number on my gurnsey since he joined the Eags

I don't know about Cica but I feel very old after reading Katilyns post

Last week:

5 - Craig Parry 38
4 - Pat Giuffreda 26
3 - Angus Rowntree 23
2 - Ben Grieger 21
1 - Jared Polec 15 (two 5s)
Scott Lewis 15 (one 5)
Luke Jarrad 9
Justin Cicolella 7
Mark McKenzie 4
Todd Miles 4
Jarrad Redden 2
Adam Grocke 1

29 - Justin Cicolella (3,2,3,3,4,5,5,1,3)
29 - Scott Lewis (1,4,4,3,1,2,3,2,4,4)
24 - Craig Parry (1,1,3,4,4,4,2,5)
20 - Luke Powell (4,1,2,2,4,3,3,1)
14 - Nick Salter (5,5,4)
14 - Patrick Giuffreda (5,5,4)
14 - Adam Grocke (1,3,5,5)
13 - Luke Jarrad (3,2,3,5)
13 - Angus Rowntree (5,2,2,1,3)
12 - Matthew Goldsworthy (5,2,5)
12 - Scott Welsh (1,2,4,1,1,3)
11 - James Stewart (4,5,2)
11 - Ben Grieger (2,2,5,2)
10 - Brad Geddes (4,2,4)
9 - Trent Hentschel (5,4)
8 - Todd Miles (5,3)
5 - Jay Schulz (5)
4 - Jay Cheep (4)
3 - Matthew Broadbent (3)
3 - Jarred Allmond (3)
3 - Nathan Bock (3)
3 - Sebastian Guilhaus (1,2)
2 - Brodie Smith (2)
2 - James Rimington (1,1)
2 - Jared Polec (1,1)

This week:

5 - Cicolella
4 - Grocke
3 - Grieger
2 - Parry
1 - McKenzie

I want to give Grocke votes every week, because he does put in 100%. It's his fault he is double teamed as such, because of this work rate. Therefore he may not get as many possessions as he deserves.

Mickyj wrote:

Kaitlyn51 wrote:

Eagle014 wrote:

Flash wrote:5 Cicca
4 Polec
3 Grieger
2 Macca
1 Parry

God help the Eagles when Cicca decides to call it a day.
Yes, he makes an odd mistake. Yes, at times, he carries an injury.
BUT! He always gives 100%

Couldn't agree more Flash. Hopefully, because he has been managed very well this year by Gods his old body may be able to go on for another year, we can only hope.
5 - Cicolella
4 - Polec
3 - Rowntree
2 - Allmond
1 - McKenzie

When Cica retires im going to be so sad he has been my favourite player since i started following the Eagles when i was 4. It was also his first year at the Eagles so i have had his number on my gurnsey since he joined the Eags

I don't know about Cica but I feel very old after reading Katilyns post

Your not old I'm just young

5 - Cica
4 - Polec
3 - Rowntree
2 - Allmond
1 - Parry

Kaitlyn51,
There is a young fellow (Angus Poole) coming up through the ranks that has an uncanny resemblance to Cica. (at least in football prowess).

Perhaps sometime down the track he may take the baton from Cica as your favourite player.

Flash wrote:Kaitlyn51,
There is a young fellow (Angus Poole) coming up through the ranks that has an uncanny resemblance to Cica. (at least in football prowess).

Perhaps sometime down the track he may take the baton from Cica as your favourite player.

Flash, you & I are definitely on the same wave length. I had him picked as a young Cica the first time I saw him. Let's hope we get to see as much of him as possible as no doubt his name is on all the AFL scouts lists.

Eagle014 wrote:

Flash wrote:Kaitlyn51,
There is a young fellow (Angus Poole) coming up through the ranks that has an uncanny resemblance to Cica. (at least in football prowess).

Perhaps sometime down the track he may take the baton from Cica as your favourite player.

Flash, you & I are definitely on the same wave length. I had him picked as a young Cica the first time I saw him. Let's hope we get to see as much of him as possible as no doubt his name is on all the AFL scouts lists.

Pretty sure young Gus won player of the week in the under 18's in the last couple of weeks...agree with both of you he's a bit of a mini cica and goes in hard like justin too.

Columbo wrote:

Eagle014 wrote:

Flash wrote:Kaitlyn51,
There is a young fellow (Angus Poole) coming up through the ranks that has an uncanny resemblance to Cica. (at least in football prowess).

Perhaps sometime down the track he may take the baton from Cica as your favourite player.

Flash, you & I are definitely on the same wave length. I had him picked as a young Cica the first time I saw him. Let's hope we get to see as much of him as possible as no doubt his name is on all the AFL scouts lists.

Pretty sure young Gus won player of the week in the under 18's in the last couple of weeks...agree with both of you he's a bit of a mini cica and goes in hard like justin too.

he even appears to have the cica strut/walk on field down pat
Love the way he goes into packs as well .

Mickyj wrote:

Columbo wrote:

Eagle014 wrote:

Flash wrote:Kaitlyn51,
There is a young fellow (Angus Poole) coming up through the ranks that has an uncanny resemblance to Cica. (at least in football prowess).

Perhaps sometime down the track he may take the baton from Cica as your favourite player.

Flash, you & I are definitely on the same wave length. I had him picked as a young Cica the first time I saw him. Let's hope we get to see as much of him as possible as no doubt his name is on all the AFL scouts lists.

Pretty sure young Gus won player of the week in the under 18's in the last couple of weeks...agree with both of you he's a bit of a mini cica and goes in hard like justin too.

he even appears to have the cica strut/walk on field down pat
Love the way he goes into packs as well .

I have seen Angus play a couple of times and love the way he plays. He is definately like Cica i have noticed that a few times.

Another difficult ask, this week.

1st half was shocking, that said...

5 - Greiger
4 - Parry
3 - Thompson
2 - Treeby (2nd half)
1 - Powell (2nd half)

5 - Smith
4 - Miles
3 - Greiger
2 - Polec
1 - Allmond

5 Greiger
4 Miles
3 Smith
2 Polec
1 Allmond

5 - Parry
4 - Greiger
3 - Polec
2 - Smith
1 - Thomson

Polec and Smith played like it was a dry day...pity we wont see much more of those two!

5 - Parry
4 - Miles
3 - Thompson
2 - Smith
1 - Polec

5 - Parry
4 - Grieger
3 - Polec
2 - Rowntree
1 - Smith

5 - Parry
4 - Greiger
3 - Thomson
2 - Polec
1 - Smith