Re: Tribunal

by Eagle014 Wed Aug 17, 2011 1:36 pm

wimpy wrote:The tribunal really worries me. The Monday after Grocke got reported (against WA) three tribunal members decided Grocke was guilty and gave him one match, of course the club had to plead not guilty as the frame by frame shots of the incident cleary showed Grockes eyes on the ball and his fist punching the ball. At the hearing on the Tuesday night the not guilty plea was upheld and rightly so. The question that has to be asked is how did three tribunal members GET IT SO WRONG in the first place!!!!!!!!!when they had video of the incident.Talk about three blind mice.l

Agree, I thought both reports on Saturday were weak. It's getting to the stage when players will start to doubt themselves when going for a mark or spoil.
I also thought it interesting that there were 4 reports last weekend & ALL were 'Not Guilty', surely it can't be that the SANFL is sick to death of the clubs complaining about trivial waste if time reports by the umpires!!!!!
We can only hope.

by zest Tue Aug 23, 2011 7:38 pm

nice to have a week when nobody's been reported

by Eagle014 Tue Aug 23, 2011 7:40 pm

zest wrote:nice to have a week when nobody's been reported

Didn't Tom Corbett get reported in the ressies???

by zest Tue Aug 30, 2011 7:06 pm

Stephen Tiller * (Eagles)
Striking

Reckless Conduct - Low Impact - Body Contact
80 Points
-45% Good Record, Guilty Plea
44 Total Points
Reprimand

by Columbo Tue Aug 30, 2011 7:43 pm

No surprise there I wouldn't have thought, hope the Souths folk who were saying he should be watching his head next time he was near the ball saw the body contact bit!

by Sponsored content